GateTrue

What each generator documents about marking its output

A named standard without a plan, and a plan without one

One entry names C2PA metadata on all assets and attaches no plan to its mark. The other names a plan for removing its mark and says nothing about what the file carries. Opposite halves of the same four columns. As of 2026-09-22.

Opposite halves of the same four columnsOne entry fills the commercial columns and leaves the file column empty; the other fills the file column and leaves the commercial ones empty. The split follows the genre of the document each statement was published in rather than anything about the companies.Read from a system cardRead from a plan tableWhat the file carriesC2PA metadata on all assetsNothing publishedWhat a plan changesNothing publishedRemoval, from ten dollars a monthThe mark on the frameVisible and movingNamed as a brand watermarkReader servedSomebody holding a fileSomebody choosing a planNeither document carries the other's content
Fig. 1 A membership table has no reason to describe a manifest, and a system card has no reason to discuss a price.
The two entries on one question at a time, in each vendor's own terms. Recorded 2026-09-22.
On this questionSoraKling AI
File contentsC2PA metadata on all assetsNothing published
Crossing pointNothing publishedTen dollars a month
Visible markDescribed as visible and movingNamed in two words
Who can check a fileThe vendor, with internal toolsNobody, nothing published
Document readA system cardA membership plan table

Inclusion rule. One row per question on which these two entries can be compared from their own published pages. Questions neither vendor addresses are left out rather than filled with a dash. Order. Fixed order: the mechanism first, then who holds it, then what it leaves behind.

Where each value above was read, and what the register records in the machine-readable marking column. Recorded 2026-09-22.
GeneratorMachine-readable markingDocument read
Kling AINot documentedmembership plans
SoraC2PA on every asset, standard namedSora 2 system card

Inclusion rule. The two entries on this page, with the value each one's own pages support in the column they diverge on. Order. Alphabetical by generator name.

1Two shapes that almost never occur in one company

Across the register a generator fills either the commercial columns or the file column, rarely both. These two entries are the cleanest example. One publishes a crossing point, a price and a benefit list, and records not documented for file contents. The other publishes a named standard, a described mark and a detection capability, and records not documented for the crossing point.

The split follows the genre of the document rather than the size or seriousness of the company. A membership table is written to sell a subscription; a system card is written to describe safeguards to a reviewer. Neither document has a reason to carry the other's content, and neither vendor has published a page that does.

2What each row lets a reader do

The plan-gated row answers a purchasing question completely: ten dollars a month removes the mark, on any of four memberships, and the figure can be quoted. It answers nothing a recipient of a file could act on, because nothing about the file is described.

The card-read row is the mirror image. A recipient learns that the file is supposed to carry a manifest in a published format and that the mark on the frame is visible and moving. A buyer learns nothing about what any subscription changes, because no subscription is mentioned.

3Neither gives a recipient a way to check

On the plan-gated row that follows from the silence: no scheme, no field, no route. On the card-read row it follows from a choice, because the detection tooling is described as internal to the vendor. A file may carry a signal and the party holding it is not the party who can interrogate it.

Two other entries in this register name a standard and a public route for reading it, which is the arrangement that helps a receiving party. Between the two on this page, one has a manifest with no public reader and the other has nothing to read at all.

4Sources

  • Machine-readable marking
    In the same list: C2PA metadata on all assets, providing verifiable origin through an industry standardstandard namedOpenAI, Sora 2 system card / recorded 2026-09-22
  • Machine-readable marking
    Not documented on the vendor's public pages (as of 2026-09-22)not mentioned in the plan tableKling AI, membership plans / recorded 2026-09-12

Both values above are read from the vendor pages linked in the rows: openai.com and kling.ai, on 2026-09-22. Each entry has its own page, Sora and Kling AI, and the rule for the column they diverge on is on the machine-readable marking column page. Other pairs: who reads the signal, inside or around.